promptfoo vs PromptLayer
Which should you use? A side-by-side look at what each one does, who it suits, what it costs, how hard it is to set up, and where each falls short.
Open source · MIT
CLI and library for testing LLM prompts and red-teaming AI apps, with declarative configs.
AI tool · Freemium
A prompt registry and logging layer that lets teams version, test and deploy prompts outside application code.
The short answer
Choose promptfoo if you need…
- Developers building apps on top of LLM APIs who want repeatable prompt tests
- Teams comparing several models side by side on the same prompts
- People who want to run automated LLM checks in CI/CD pipelines
- Teams looking for a local, command-line way to scan LLM apps for security issues
Choose PromptLayer if you need…
- Non-engineers editing production prompts
- Versioning prompts across releases
Side-by-side
| promptfoo | PromptLayer | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Dev tool | Prompting · Prompt managers |
| Price | Free and open source | Freemium |
| Licence | MIT | — |
| GitHub stars | 26.7k | — |
| Setup difficulty | Intermediate | — |
| How you get it | Install with a package manager | — |
| Platforms | CLI, Web | Web, API |
| Works with | GitHub, OpenAI, Anthropic | OpenAI, Anthropic, LangChain |
| Main language | TypeScript | — |
| Last code update | 4 days ago | — |
| Hands-on tested by us | — | Not yet |
| Last checked | — | 2026-10-29 |
What each one is
promptfoo
Promptfoo is a command-line tool and library for evaluating LLM-based apps. You write a declarative config listing prompts, models, and test cases, then run it to compare outputs across providers such as OpenAI, Anthropic, and Ollama. It also includes red-teaming features that scan AI apps for security vulnerabilities.
PromptLayer
A prompt registry and logging layer that lets teams version, test and deploy prompts outside application code. Clean separation of prompts from code. Adds another service to your request path, so weigh latency and data-retention terms.
Best for
promptfoo
- Developers building apps on top of LLM APIs who want repeatable prompt tests
- Teams comparing several models side by side on the same prompts
- People who want to run automated LLM checks in CI/CD pipelines
- Teams looking for a local, command-line way to scan LLM apps for security issues
PromptLayer
- Non-engineers editing production prompts
- Versioning prompts across releases
Strengths
promptfoo
- The README states that evals run locally and prompts never leave your machine
- Works with many providers and any LLM API, according to the README
- Has a large community with about 26,500 stars and an MIT license
PromptLayer
- Visual prompt registry with versions
- Request logging
- A/B releases
- Evaluation pipelines
Not ideal for
promptfoo
- People who want a no-code, point-and-click tool, since the workflow centers on the command line and config files
- Projects that do not call any LLM APIs, because there is nothing for it to evaluate
- Anyone who needs a guaranteed security audit, since the README describes scanning as a tool rather than a complete assurance
PromptLayer
—
Trade-offs
promptfoo
- The README says the project is now part of OpenAI, which may matter to some users evaluating independence
- Requires API keys for most providers, which means usage costs from those providers
- Some claims in the README, such as usage by OpenAI and Anthropic and serving 10M+ users, are not independently verified here
PromptLayer
—
Getting started
promptfoo
Install globally with npm
npm install -g promptfooCreate a starter example
promptfoo init --example getting-startedPromptLayer
Get started on the PromptLayer websiteFrequently asked questions
What is the difference between promptfoo and PromptLayer?
promptfoo: CLI and library for testing LLM prompts and red-teaming AI apps, with declarative configs. PromptLayer: A prompt registry and logging layer that lets teams version, test and deploy prompts outside application code. promptfoo suits developers building apps on top of llm apis who want repeatable prompt tests, while PromptLayer suits non-engineers editing production prompts.
Are promptfoo and PromptLayer free?
promptfoo: Free and open source. PromptLayer: Freemium.
What are other alternatives to promptfoo and PromptLayer?
Other options people compare them with include Composio, Prompt flow, Portkey AI Gateway, lm-evaluation-harness, book-to-skill.
Keep comparing
Built from our catalogue entries for both products: open-source details come from each project's README (AI-assisted, refreshed weekly) and GitHub data; AI-tool details are editorial. Spotted something wrong? Let us know from either product's page.